Skip to Content

Double Jeopardy Law: Can You Be Tried Twice?

The rule against double jeopardy has protected defendants for centuries—but recent reforms allow retrials in exceptional cases.

The principle of double jeopardy means that once a person has been acquitted of a crime, they cannot be tried again for the same offence. This protection dates back over 800 years and was designed to uphold finality in criminal proceedings and prevent state overreach.

Historically, two key doctrines applied:

- Autrefois acquit: A bar to retrial after acquittal.

- Autrefois convict: A bar to retrial after conviction.

Courts also treated it as an abuse of process to bring fresh charges based on the same facts.

2003 Reform: A Shift in the Balance.

The Criminal Justice Act 2003, Part 10, introduced a major exception. In cases involving serious offences—such as murder—the Court of Appeal may now quash an acquittal and order a retrial if:

- The original trial ended in acquittal.

- New and compelling evidence has emerged, strongly indicating guilt.

Examples include:

- DNA or fingerprint evidence was unavailable at the time of the trial.

- New witnesses or confessions.

How It Works Today:

- Retrials are permitted only for the most serious crimes.

- The Court of Appeal must approve the application.

- The evidence must be both new and compelling—not previously available and highly probative.

This reform aims to strike a balance between the historic protection of defendants and the pursuit of justice in light of modern forensic advancements.

Disclaimer: Solicitors.com is not a firm of solicitors. Content on this site is not legal advice and should not replace consultation with a regulated solicitor. We strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information; however, no content is guaranteed to be completely accurate. Using this site does not establish a client relationship.

Feedback: Is there anything wrong with this page? Amendments may receive accreditation—email us.

Double Jeopardy Law: Can You Be Tried Twice?
Image Description
related news
recent articles
Double Jeopardy Law

What is Double Jeopardy? and is it still Law in the UK?..

link

Children and the Law - Smacking

Children and the Law - Smacking.
It is surprising that the UK have not adopted the same stance as in Europe where the EU have adopted a clearer stance in makin..

Handling Stolen Goods

What is meant by 'handling stolen goods'...

Bail

What is Bail in the UK - If you have been charged with a crime you can be released on bail from the police station, which means you will be able to go home but..

What is a Section 60 notice?

Over 2000 section 60 notices have been issued in London last year..

link

Children and the Law Consensual Sex

Children and the Law Consensual Sex
To consent is to agree to something, so when you are talking about the age of consent it is the age at which that law state..

New Guidelines for online hate crimes.

New guidelines have been issued to crack down on online hate...

Motoring Offences | Drink Driving.

Motoring Offences - Drink Driving.
If you have been stopped for drink driving it is important that you obtain legal advice as soon as possible and, to assist y..

Stop and Search Laws to be changed?

Police Chiefs are calling for a change in the 'stop and search' l..

link

Reporting a Crime.

If the crime is ongoing call 999, you should not put yours or anyone else’s safety at risk by taking action yourself...

Clare`s Law - Domestic Violence.

The domestic violence disclosure scheme named after domestic violence victim Clare Wood has been brought in throughout England and Wales. If you feel you could..

Criminal Law

..

Image Description
Is there anything wrong with this page? - any amendments will receive accreditation - email us

Solicitors.com are not a firm of solicitors, and any content on the site should not be used in substitute for obtaining Legal advice from a solicitor regulated in the UK, Solicitors.com recommends that you contact a firm of solicitors to discuss your individual legal requirement. Whilst we strive to bring you accurate up to date content, all content on this site is not legal advice and is not guaranteed to be correct. Use of this site does not create a client relationship.

Information by area of law
Back to top